Start & choose channels

How to compare online selling costs using your own figures

Build a like-for-like monthly cost comparison without treating unknown fees, owner time or refunds as free.

Your task: compare the total cost of handling the same set of orders through two selling arrangements. Create one shared order scenario, apply each arrangement’s current charges and keep setup costs, recurring costs and owner time visible. Do not compare a headline percentage with a subscription price and call the cheaper figure the answer.

This is an operational comparison method. It supplies no current platform fees and does not select accounting or tax treatment. Enter all NZD figures on a consistent basis and ask your adviser if you are unsure how to handle tax.

Define the basket of orders first

Choose a period, such as one month, and write down order count, average product revenue after discounts, shipping charged and typical product cost. Include the destinations, package sizes and payment methods you expect to use. If orders differ substantially, divide them into two or three groups instead of forcing everything into one average.

Use the same scenario for both options. If one comparison assumes twenty orders and another assumes eighty, differences may come from the assumptions rather than the platform.

For an established shop, use a recent complete period and note unusual promotions or stock shortages. For a new shop, label the estimate as a scenario rather than a forecast. Test low, middle and higher order counts so a single hopeful number does not determine the decision.

Build three cost sections

First list setup costs: configuration, design, initial listing work and any migration. Keep them separate; spreading a setup charge over twelve months is useful only when you state that assumption.

Next list recurring fixed costs: subscriptions, paid extensions and other charges that apply regardless of that month’s orders. Some plans have usage thresholds, so check whether your scenario crosses one.

Finally list variable costs: product cost, delivery, packaging, payment or marketplace fees, and an explicit advertising allocation. Determine exactly what a percentage charge applies to. It may apply to a different amount from the product price you first had in mind. Read the provider’s current fee documentation and keep its URL and observation date. To see how percentage fees change the price you need, read setting a selling price that covers percentage fees.

Where a charge is unknown, write “quote needed”. Do not enter zero merely to make the spreadsheet calculate. You can still compare known costs while clearly labelling the result incomplete.

Work through a simple example

Illustrative scenario, not platform pricing: thirty identical orders each bring in NZ$90 for products and NZ$8 for shipping. Revenue is therefore NZ$2,940. Product, delivery and packaging costs total NZ$62 per order, or NZ$1,860 for the month.

Assumed cost Arrangement A Arrangement B
Manually entered fees per order NZ$4 NZ$6
Fees for thirty orders NZ$120 NZ$180
Recurring monthly service costs NZ$60 NZ$15
Known monthly costs including goods and fulfilment NZ$2,040 NZ$2,055
Revenue less those listed costs NZ$900 NZ$885

Under these assumptions A leaves NZ$15 more before advertising, owner time and other overheads. The small difference is not a prediction of net profit. At ten orders, the fixed costs matter more; at a hundred, the fee difference matters more. Recalculate rather than generalising from the thirty-order case.

Add the costs of exceptions

Test a refund, a replacement parcel and a failed delivery. Check which fees are returned, which delivery costs remain and how much staff work is involved under the actual terms. If you cannot estimate an exception rate, show a separate “one replacement this month” scenario.

Avoid counting the same expense twice. For example, an advertising allocation entered in each order should not also appear as a full monthly advertising charge. Document where shared expenses sit.

Keep hours beside money. “Five hours of manual order entry” remains useful even if you do not attach a wage value. If you do attach one, label it an assumed opportunity cost and show the cash-only result too.

Make a decision with the limits visible

Compare capability and risk alongside cost. A lower-cost arrangement may require a process you cannot sustain; a higher-cost one may still offer no benefit for your actual order mix. Do not assign a monetary saving to an untested integration.

Save the assumptions, evidence date and result so you can repeat the comparison after a billing or workflow change. Use the per-order contribution calculator to check a representative order, then bring the monthly result into your weekly review. Your next action is to resolve the largest unknown charge before committing to a plan.

Put this guide to work


Spot something that needs correcting? Send a correction. See our editorial policy and commercial disclosures.

Keep moving

Customers & improvement

Understanding contribution per order

Separate revenue from variable costs and see what remains to cover overheads, owner time and other omitted costs.

4 min readguide